Building one sheet
Make a simple table with one column per college. In the rows, list the direct costs, the estimated indirect costs, the total gift aid, any work-study and any loans. Copy figures from each offer into the same row, even when the colleges label them differently.
Then work out the net price for each column: the cost of attendance minus grants and scholarships. Keep loans and work-study in their own rows, because they are not the same as gift aid.
Things that do not show on the page
Ask how each grant renews. One college may keep a scholarship at the same level for four years if you keep a grade average, while another may award it only for the first year. The renewal rules are printed in the scholarship terms or available from the aid office.
Look at the estimated costs too. One college may estimate housing and food generously and another may not, which changes the totals without changing what you would really pay.
Keep loans and work-study in their own rows, because they are not the same as gift aid.
When one offer is lower
Some colleges will look at another college's offer and reconsider their own, and others will not. This kind of request is separate from a special circumstances review, and the college sets the rules. Ask the aid office whether it accepts these requests and what it wants you to send.
Graduate students can ask the department as well, since assistantship terms are often set there. A clear, polite request with the other offer attached is easier to answer.
Keeping the reply date in view
Each college sets its own reply date, and many use May 1. A comparison that drags into late April leaves little room for a review request or a follow-up call. Aim to have the sheet finished by the first week of April.
Keep the sheet after you decide. It shows what was offered for the first year, which helps when the next year's offer arrives and you want to see what changed.



